Built-to-Rent Homes Surge in Charlotte, Raising Market Concerns

February 3, 2025

In recent years, the housing market in Charlotte, North Carolina, has witnessed a significant shift towards built-to-rent homes, with the city leading the state in the number of such communities. The idea of constructing homes specifically for renting rather than selling has gained traction, particularly among families looking for a flexible and temporary living arrangement. This trend places North Carolina as the second-highest state in the nation for built-to-rent homes, just behind Phoenix, Arizona. However, as this development continues to grow in popularity, it raises several important concerns about the ramifications on the overall housing market.

The Rising Popularity of Built-to-Rent Homes

A Flexible Option for Many Families

The appeal of built-to-rent homes lies primarily in their ability to provide a housing option for individuals or families who are not ready to commit to purchasing a property. Sheryl De Sa and her husband, for instance, found this to be an attractive solution while deciding on a long-term purchase in Charlotte’s University City neighborhood. Renting a home offers them the flexibility to live in a comfortable space without the pressures and financial commitments associated with buying one outright. This temporary arrangement allows them the necessary time to make a deliberate and well-informed decision about their future home.

Despite the flexibility offered, the cost aspect cannot be overlooked. Renting a built-to-rent home does not always translate to savings. For many families, like the De Sas, renting is not a cost-saving measure but a strategic choice to avoid the immediate financial burden of a mortgage. The absence of upfront costs and freedom from maintenance responsibilities are attractive benefits, but the rental expenses can still be significant. This nuanced reality underscores the appeal of built-to-rent homes for those needing an interim solution while planning their future in the housing market, emphasizing the balancing act between short-term needs and long-term goals.

Impact on the Housing Market

Reduced Inventory for Potential Buyers

While the increase in built-to-rent homes offers a workable solution for some, it simultaneously raises concerns about its impact on the broader housing market. Critics like real estate agent Trev Swint argue that the proliferation of these rental properties reduces the available inventory for potential buyers. This situation exacerbates an existing shortage in the real estate market, making it harder for buyers to find homes. According to the Canopy Realtor Association, there has been a reported 24% increase in market inventory. However, this is insufficient, with only a little over two months of available homes, falling short of the six months’ worth of inventory deemed necessary for a balanced market by the National Association of Realtors.

Swint’s observations highlight a troubling trend where the rising number of rental properties over the past two decades has come at the expense of homes for sale. Although renting offers benefits like avoiding upfront costs and sparing tenants from maintenance expenses, it does place pressure on homeownership opportunities. Programs exist to assist first-time buyers with down payments, but the reduced inventory means that even with financial aid, potential buyers face a competitive and limited market. This reduction in available homes for sale poses a significant challenge to achieving a balanced housing market, where the distribution between renting and buying opportunities is equitable.

Balancing Short-Term Flexibility and Long-Term Supply

In recent years, the housing market in Charlotte, North Carolina, has seen a major shift toward built-to-rent homes. With the city leading the state in the number of these communities, the concept of constructing homes specifically for renting rather than selling has gained traction. This trend is particularly appealing to families seeking a flexible and temporary living arrangement. North Carolina now ranks as the second-highest state in the nation for built-to-rent homes, trailing only Phoenix, Arizona. As this development grows in popularity, it raises several important concerns about the potential impact on the broader housing market. Issues such as housing availability, affordability, and the balance between rental and ownership opportunities need closer examination. The increased emphasis on built-to-rent properties might limit the options for homebuyers, leading to a more competitive market and potentially higher prices. The trend also prompts discussions on urban planning, community stability, and long-term economic implications for the region.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest.

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for Subscribing!
We'll be sending you our best soon!
Something went wrong, please try again later